By Louis ‘Barok‘ C. Biraogo — December 4, 2024

ALFRED Vargas’s triumphant third Best Actor win for Pieta—an emotionally charged mother-son suspense drama—is nothing short of a revelation. If ever there was a moment when an actor not only found his voice but wielded it like a weapon, this is it. Vargas, often overshadowed in his earlier work by the specter of being a reliable but unspectacular leading man, has broken through with a performance that feels both inevitable and astonishing.

Pieta, helmed by Adolf Alix and bolstered by the titanic presence of Nora Aunor and Gina Alajar, is the kind of film that demands an actor rise to the occasion—or crumble under its weight. Vargas not only rises; he soars. His portrayal is raw, unvarnished, and utterly captivating—a man grappling with moral decay, familial redemption, and existential despair, all while maintaining a deep undercurrent of vulnerability. The quiet moments—an unspoken plea in his eyes, the trembling of a hand—are where his brilliance lies. He achieves that rare feat of making suffering a symphony, turning every grimace into a masterstroke of restrained agony.

It’s hard to reconcile this performance with the Vargas of yesteryear. His earlier roles in melodramas and fantasy series like Encantadia showed an actor with charm but limited range, content to tread familiar waters. One recalls his tendency to lean too heavily on stock gestures—brooding glares, anguished yells—that betrayed an actor working within his comfort zone. Yet even in those missteps, there was a hint of latent potential, an earnestness that suggested he could someday deliver something extraordinary.

And then, the turning point: Pieta. Working alongside legends like Aunor and Alajar—actors who could eclipse even seasoned performers—seems to have awakened in Vargas a fierce determination to prove his mettle. Alix’s direction, no doubt, played a crucial role in refining his craft, demanding the kind of nuanced performance that forces an actor to strip away pretense.

The awards—three and counting—are not merely accolades but declarations: Vargas has arrived. Still, the question lingers: is this a peak, or the beginning of a lasting renaissance?

Hollywood has its doors ajar for international talent, yet it’s a fickle beast. Vargas’s strength lies in his ability to channel profound emotion, a skill that transcends language and culture. If he can avoid the trap of becoming pigeonholed in heavy dramas and instead embrace a range of genres—while maintaining the emotional depth he’s now proven capable of—his star could burn bright on the global stage.

Yet there’s also the risk of complacency, of allowing the three-peat to define him rather than propel him. The narrative of the underdog who “makes it” can quickly curdle if the follow-up lacks the same intensity. Vargas must now tread carefully, selecting roles that challenge rather than flatter him.

For now, though, let us revel in the moment. Vargas’s Pieta is a reminder of what cinema can do at its best: transform, transcend, and transport. His win isn’t just a personal victory; it’s a testament to Filipino talent staking its claim on the world stage. As for Vargas? He’s not merely an actor anymore; he’s a force.

• “Forthwith” to Farce: How the Senate is Killing Impeachment—And Why Enrile’s Right (Even If You Can’t Trust Him)
• “HINDI AKO NAG-RESIGN!”
• “I’m calling you from my new Globe SIM. Send load!”
• “Mahiya Naman Kayo!” Marcos’ Anti-Corruption Vow Faces a Flood of Doubt
• “Meow, I’m calling you from my new Globe SIM!”
• “PLUNDER IS OVERRATED”? TRY AGAIN — IT’S A CALCULATED KILL SHOT
• “Shimenet”: The Term That Broke the Internet and the Budget
• “We Did Not Yield”: Marcos’s Stand and the Soul of Filipino Sovereignty
• “We Gather Light to Scatter”: A Tribute to Edgardo Bautista Espiritu
• $150M for Kaufman to Spin a Sinking Narrative
• $2 Trillion by 2050? Manila’s Economic Fantasy Flimsier Than a Taho Cup 
• $26 Short of Glory: The Philippines’ Economic Hunger Games Flop